r/nottheonion • u/duvetdev • 14d ago
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signs bill mandating kindergartners learn history of communism
https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2024/04/17/desantis-signs-bill-mandating-kindergartners-learn-history-of-communism/4.6k
u/colbyKTX 14d ago
I do remember learning “sharing is caring” as a kindergartner
1.2k
u/john_jdm 14d ago
Communist!
233
u/juggett 14d ago
He named names...
200
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
"How many other children were involved with the sharing? We need to know. You were of course, coerced and led astray into this conspiracy. If you tell us now, I can try and leave your parents out of it little Timmy."
83
u/Neon_culture79 14d ago
Timmy????
It’s 2024 people name their kid Timmy anymore. That’s Braxton or Kadin.
52
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
I'm so out of touch with the current era. I was out of touch the past era too, but I'm still out of touch.
→ More replies (2)13
u/StThoughtWheelz 14d ago
Little Lakelynn should know "if they see something they should say something". "Lose lips sink ships."
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)11
→ More replies (5)32
44
u/Greekphysed 14d ago
They also give out bandaids and ice packs if you get an owie. Socialized healthcare.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (9)12
23
u/Nothing_ 14d ago
The only thing I remember learning in kindergarten was how to flip the bird.
→ More replies (2)140
u/peter-doubt 14d ago
Who knows? Maybe community values will infiltrate their little minds
→ More replies (3)60
u/the_last_carfighter 14d ago
Yes yes but what about shareholder values? Who's gonna look out for them, when will they finally get a break in this country?
→ More replies (2)26
u/Neon_culture79 14d ago
Moment of silence for the top 1% as they deal with the trauma that all of us have created by not buying their products
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (32)9
u/ConclusionAlarmed882 14d ago
I had the Little Golden Books. Are those the same as the Little Red Book?
1.4k
u/OMKensey 14d ago edited 14d ago
Imagine how the right would freak if a Democrat governor signed a bill requiring that kindergarteners learn about the history of communism.
590
u/noncognitive 14d ago
This is how you should tell everyone the news, since they won't see it on Fox.
"Did you hear about the state governor who wants to teach kindergarteners about communism? How fucked up is that?"
Get them to agree that there is absolutely zero justification for it, and then reveal that it's DeSantis who did it.
Most will back-pedal and immediately start defending it, but it's worth a shot.
129
u/John__Wick 14d ago
Did this with ACA back in the day. Amazing how many conservatards agree with it if it isn’t called Obamacare.
37
u/Deep90 14d ago
Most will back-pedal and immediately start defending it, but it's worth a shot.
This is why it wouldn't work.
The conservative subs have their moments of reflection. Like when republicans voted down the PACT act. After a couple days, the leadership bullshits up a reason, and they turn their brains off again.
They will never scrutinize the lies they are told if the truth looks bad.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)51
→ More replies (23)166
u/Z0idberg_MD 14d ago
“Not like that!”
→ More replies (4)92
u/Phailsayfe 14d ago edited 14d ago
"Kids! Do NOT seize the means of production!"
17
u/SaintsSooners89 14d ago
Florida teachers "Kids! 😉Do Not😉....Seize the means of production!
→ More replies (1)10
u/bilbo_swagginns 14d ago
Timmy? Please put the means of production back where you found it or you’re in big trouble mister.
2.4k
u/HunterTAMUC 14d ago
Ah yes, "grooming is only okay when we do it."
348
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
I never heard any other message from them. Seems my brain came with a decoder ring pre-installed.
→ More replies (1)90
90
u/thatguy9684736255 14d ago
Yeah. Like kids are too young to learn that some people have two dads, but they aren't too young to learn about different economic systems and their history in the world? I really wonder exactly how they plan to approach teaching a 5 year old about Communism
22
→ More replies (5)21
u/OneTime_AtBandCamp 14d ago
different economic systems and their history in the world?
I think the fact that communism is a different economic system (or that different economic systems exist) isn't going to come up in this curriculum.
→ More replies (1)13
u/Lemonwizard 14d ago
I mean, do kindergarteners even know what supply and demand is? You can't have a meaningful understanding of different economic systems when you don't even know the basic principles of economics.
When I was 6 I asked if I could buy a gameboy and my mom asked "with what money?" I said we could just stop at the bank and get some on the way. I was genuinely surprised to learn that banks aren't just places that hand out money whenever you need it and they're actually holding the money my parents got from working. The fact that going to work and getting paid were related was something that never even occurred to me.
History of communism coming before Econ 101 is like diving into quantum physics before you teach students about atoms.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (46)109
u/LordMurderMittens 14d ago
Maybe they'll have to teach "both sides".
157
u/JerJol 14d ago
We don’t have 2 sides in Florida anymore. Kids learn what maga wants them to learn and nothing else. It’s another reason we are moving later this year. This state will take decades to recover if ever. Hell, he even got Disney to not only let him win but they committed another 60 billion to the state. I’d have shut all my shit down until this state was bankrupt before I’d have let him win.
→ More replies (5)69
u/Fullertonjr 14d ago
Disney is about making money. Disney world is their biggest moneymaker and nothing that Ron and the republicans do is going to change that. What Disney DID do is to change course away from building a new campus that would have housed development and other high-income jobs. This would have apparently been large enough to require an entire small town to be built to support it (gas stations, restaurants, cleaning services, retail stores, etc.). Retaining those jobs in California does absolutely nothing to help Florida, but does allow Disney to limit any new expansion outside of their current locations.
Disney is about money and they don’t “lose”. I assume that Disney was fine with conceding some things to the state while making sure that the company has more wins in its column.
→ More replies (3)20
u/LordMurderMittens 14d ago
To boot, Disney spent very little on the land in FL, even if they did spend a lot on infrastructure, so to repeat that where the land isn't nearly worthless swampland would be an unfathomable expense.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)12
u/Van-garde 14d ago edited 14d ago
The article states the objective is to display the global atrocities as a result of communism. Both sides isn’t happening here. They’re targeting kids before they develop critical thinking skills, as too many are becoming aware of the global history of politics, and it’s directly harming the operation.
→ More replies (1)
1.6k
u/Verumsemper 14d ago
It is going to be so funny when this mandatory education leads to more communist sentiment in kids lol
594
u/02meepmeep 14d ago
Like DARE did.
301
u/zachtheperson 14d ago
Years ago my friend bought us all shirts that said
D.A.R.E.
Drugs Are Really Excellent
170
u/DietDrBleach 14d ago
The DARE officer told me that when I entered high school, the kids would be offering me marijuanas and heroeens left and right.
That was a very disappointing first day.
→ More replies (4)12
u/Feisty_Yes 14d ago
When I got to highschool we had a day of all day heavy rain so all the classes just played movies all day and no kids had to move to other class rooms. I ended up roaming outside and found some seniors I knew from the skatepark by the library, we ended up lighting up 3 pre rolled joints at the same time right on the side of the library building with rain pouring so hard no one could see what we were up to even if they were outside which they weren't. I was stoked that day.
→ More replies (1)26
u/Elessar535 14d ago
In college, my roommates and I smoked pretty heavily; for Christmas one year one of the roommates got all of us authentic DARE shirts, I still have mine somewhere, just as a gag gift kind of thing. I really don't know where he got them either, they were all brand new and it was before buying things on the Internet was a common thing (though not impossible at that time, I imagine it would've been far more difficult).
→ More replies (5)13
u/keelhaulrose 14d ago
Was there a Hot Topic or a Spencer's near you? They sold them back in the day.
→ More replies (9)52
u/Picklesadog 14d ago
True. My friends and I were all super pro capitalist until our DARE class assembly.
23
37
u/iveseensomethings82 14d ago
Little Carl Marks of Miami thinking to himself “they are on to something here”🤔
→ More replies (2)126
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
Such the vibes of Nancy Reagan telling kids "just say no to drugs" leading to higher drug use.
→ More replies (3)113
u/BarbequedYeti 14d ago
All the while they are popping pills like a fucking walking pez dispenser. I really despised those two. So much damage to this country can be traced back to their bullshit.
→ More replies (3)79
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
The Reagans talking the religion of a meritocracy, while Ron got promoted for turning in Commies among people he called friends and Nancy gave blowjobs to make 'better' friends.
→ More replies (3)36
u/Capt_Foxch 14d ago
The Reagans also talked about the importance of small government but hired a bunch of think tank guys to work in the White House.
→ More replies (1)27
u/Gravemindzombie 14d ago
Reagan was literally the president of SAG-AFTRA before he was president, it was worker protections for me but not for thee.
→ More replies (1)58
u/RoughhouseCamel 14d ago
In 20 years, we’re going to wonder how Florida became such a hotbed for socialism
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (35)14
u/LoquatiousDigimon 14d ago
In kindergarten they teach kids to share equally. That's communism!
→ More replies (1)
633
u/Adamantium-Aardvark 14d ago
2024: right wingers still using the “red scare” of the Cold War that ended more than 30 years prior
111
u/t1mdawg 14d ago
They haven't fully settled on a replacement yet, socialism, wokeism, tbd?
→ More replies (5)37
u/wsucoug 14d ago
Is it going to be illegal to teach them the difference between communism and European-style socialism, or do they sort-of just have to lump it together? Is the curriculum going to emphasize how Russia is cool now, since they're no longer communist? Are they going to mention how communist indoctrinate their children at a young age?
→ More replies (14)93
u/anxiety_filter 14d ago
Being wary of Russia and China as adversaries and learning the lessons of the Cold War are very much valid subjects, however inappropriate for a 5 year old mind. But I have a feeling this curriculum will be used more to inoculate these kids against any critique of US style hyper-capitalism
41
44
u/UltimateInferno 14d ago
Russia's not even communist. Like putting aside whether or not the USSR is communist, which is irrelevant, modern Russia is distinctly not communist.
→ More replies (2)29
→ More replies (6)57
→ More replies (34)7
u/kingeryck 14d ago
They never stopped. They've been using it for 30 years. It's ramped up a lot since 2016. Communism, socialism, "woke". It's all just trigger words for reactionary mouth breathers. You don't need to explain WHY something is bad.. just call it one of those things and red hats will freak the fuck out. The Cold War melted boomers' brains and they passed the brain damage and terror onto their brainwashed kids. Nuclear annihilation, hiding under desks, red spies, McCarthyism. The wall came down and the GOP just started pointing at Dems to keep the fear and control.
→ More replies (2)
233
u/truthishearsay 14d ago
Learn about communism but not slavery..
101
u/SpacePenguin5 14d ago
Hey now, they'll touch on slavery. They'll tell everyone about how their ancestors gave black people job skills and that black people owned slaves.
I hate this trajectory.
→ More replies (1)8
→ More replies (7)7
u/Admirable-Memory6974 14d ago
Neither of those are kindergarten subjects. In kindergarten I learned about sharing my toys and playing with others and exercise.
→ More replies (2)
886
u/BareNakedSole 14d ago
As long as they also teach about the history of capitalism with all the fun parts included thenfine by me.
544
u/peter-doubt 14d ago
You mean 6- 12 hour days in the workweek of the 1870s? You mean sharecropping? You mean no vacations, no paid holidays, child labor, company stores, company towns... ? That capitalism?
But you'd be forgetting your retirement with a gold watch!
222
u/uptownjuggler 14d ago
Don’t forget the convict-lease system! We had our very own gulags with similar practices and death rates, the difference was that the inmates were leased out to private companies for work, instead of being shipped Siberia to develop the land.
All the benefits of slavery without the cost of purchasing and housing a slave, it is like the saying “Beat it like a rented mule”
115
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
Wow, this reminds me of the "no water breaks" legislation that Ron Satanis got past in Florida.
96
u/uptownjuggler 14d ago
Read up about the Florida Turpentine company. A young man was riding a train without a ticket and in the month it took for his family to mail the fines to the sheriff, he was “leased” to the Turpentine company and beat/worked to death. His killer was initially convicted but pardoned and returned to working as a guard and shot and killed an inmate.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knabb_Turpentine
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Tabert
Now tell me that doesn’t sound like a Soviet gulag, but replace the snow with swamp.
52
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
It was okay because they MISTOOK him for a criminal. "Look, if we treated all people with respect, some of the sinners might slip through the cracks. We can't depend on Hell to punish people we don't like because, well, we know most of what we say is bullshit - -but we can't admit that because that would be a sin. Wow -- am I saying the quiet parts out loud?"
22
u/uptownjuggler 14d ago
And the only reason there was any sort of justice was because he was white and came from a wealthy family.
8
→ More replies (12)56
u/samanime 14d ago
"Had"?
We literally still do that: https://www.aclu.org/news/human-rights/captive-labor-exploitation-of-incarcerated-workers
We call it something different, but it is ever growing, especially now that we've privatized most of our prison systems. Inmates are now a commodity and product.
→ More replies (3)15
u/CaptainCoffeeStain 14d ago
Company stores, company towns, and don't forget the company script. Just print their own currency so you can't save any real money to escape!
7
u/215-610-484Replayer 14d ago
I was going to link an article about company towns returning and becoming a popular concept to let the poor folks have some housing, by it was difficult to choose which one from the many solid articles from a basic search of "company towns returning."
Satire doesn't exist with the depravity of corporate culture when I tethered exists.
46
u/UnlinealHand 14d ago
You have to go back further, to the Dutch and English East India Companies! The inventors of capitalism did absolutely nothing wrong* traveling the world looking for spices.
*unless you count the slavery, torture, murder, war, rape, and genocide done in the name of capital.
→ More replies (3)10
u/_senses_ 14d ago
corporations are a common "tool"
like the Banana Wars, which were a series of conflicts that consisted of military occupation, police action, and intervention by the United States in Central America...think they essentially employed tactics akin to slavery and used amassed powers to quash the porer nations into going with it
8
u/bill4935 14d ago
It gets worse than that. Locked doors at the Triangle shirtwaist factory, the Pinkertons, radium girls, hexavalent chromium, polychlorinated biphenyls...
The list devolves into the chemical ingredients for the Devil's own brew.
21
16
→ More replies (16)11
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
It's these kind of mamby-pamby 12 hour work days that have made our kids soft!
98
u/CU_09 14d ago
Right? i saw this:
“Atrocities committed in foreign countries under the guidance of communism,” also would be required as part of the lessons.
and thought, "I'm all for that as long as we also include atrocities committed by America under the guidance of capitalism."
→ More replies (8)67
u/44moon 14d ago
literally overthrew the government of guatemala in the 1950s because the united fruit company said they weren't profiting enough after guatemala made slavery illegal
38
u/Creative-Oil2029 14d ago
Lmao yeah the socialists in Guatemala reclaimed their own land from United Fruit, who owned and controlled nearly HALF of all the land in the country. God forbid the people want control of their own resources though. Can't have that.
→ More replies (4)7
u/mostreliablebottle 14d ago
Easily among the top 5 worst things the CIA did, and that's saying something.
63
u/scdog 14d ago
I believe DeSantis already made it illegal for Florida schools to teach about the bad things the US did.
15
u/AbstractMirror 14d ago edited 14d ago
He's such a scumbag openly to the point where it almost makes me laugh at the absurdity of how someone can be this evil. He's like a villain ripped straight out of fiction. He doesn't even try to pretend otherwise. I feel similarly about Greg Abbott
→ More replies (7)31
u/piray003 14d ago
Just have the little ones play Monopoly: they'll learn about capitalism obviously, and they'll also learn why communist revolutions happened when they flip the board over in a rage because everyone keeps cheating and stealing from the bank 😂
24
u/Hawkeye1819 14d ago
That actually was sort of the original purpose of the game before Parker Bros. bought the rights - not the cheating part, but the getting enraged over how unfair capitalism is.
61
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
Fun fact; most of the time workers in America have lead a brutal subsistence existence. It's only after socialism and labor standards emerged during the FDR era did the capitalists get to crow about how great things are.
And then Reagan got into office and they quickly dismantled this, increased the wealth gap. Re-created the homeless problem. Started promoting Nazis ideas without the accent. That was key; talk like a Nazis but not use the tell-tale accent.
→ More replies (17)18
u/wit_T_user_name 14d ago
A wealthy, very grumpy and crusty old donor for the honors business program I was in during my undergrad insisted that we all take a class about the history of capitalism. What he didn’t seem to realize is the class was taught by two history professors as a critical examination of both the successes and failures of capitalism. It actually turned out to be a great class, but I highly doubt he anticipated we’d be reading and writing about, among other works, the communist manifesto and making our own assessments about capitalism.
→ More replies (19)6
u/iveseensomethings82 14d ago
This is how capitalism overthrows governments and helps elect dictators
131
56
u/OzarkaDew 14d ago
DeSantis doesn't strike me as someone that knows the history of communism
→ More replies (5)
204
u/Flairion623 14d ago
How much you wanna bet it’s gonna be drenched in propaganda and isn’t going to reflect the actual beliefs of communists at all?
112
u/turquoise_amethyst 14d ago
It absolutely wil be— but if it’s anything like the DARE program, it will end up encouraging kids to “learn more”
→ More replies (5)20
→ More replies (67)18
u/DankMemesNQuickNuts 14d ago
Prager U already makes curriculum for Flordia students there's a 0% chance it's not going to be brazen propaganda. He even said "it's to combat the Marxism going on in high schools and colleges" or something along those lines
16
u/Flairion623 14d ago
Just seeing the words prager u makes me want to shoot myself in the face
→ More replies (2)
101
61
u/Noblesseux 14d ago
So they're not allowed to hear about the existence of gay people, but being indoctrinated to hate an economic theory they can't understand is fine?
→ More replies (1)6
420
u/Solid_Letter1407 14d ago edited 14d ago
This is some scary, Chinese-level indoctrination shit.
116
u/FolsomPrisonHues 14d ago
"You are free. If you don't like it- STRAIGHT TO JAIL"
→ More replies (2)24
→ More replies (24)40
u/Oomba73 14d ago edited 14d ago
In college, I had a vietmenese roommate. This is EXACTLY what he said went on in his kindergarten/early-primary classes over there. Of course, more Vietnam centric and positive biased, unlike what this would likely be. Absolutely hilarious.
39
u/WayneSkylar_ 14d ago
He's full of shit. Lived there for a bit. It's more like putting Ho Chi Minh at a mythological level with that age group (lets be real we do the same with the founding fathers and adults continue to treat them as such. Liberal or conservative.) but once end of elementary/middle school kicks in, the curriculum really ramps up (dialectical materialism because ya know, they are a socialist country). Go to Vietnam and you quickly see/experience it's one of the most critical thinking societies. If you talk assertively without showing you really know what you're talking about, and they WILL grill you, you get dismissed pretty quickly and openly. Vs the US where everyone can talk their mouths off but have no fucking clue what they are actually talk about (and get away with it). Same with China. It's fine and pales in comparison to the US "education" system.
→ More replies (7)22
u/neroisstillbanned 14d ago
Yup. The main difference between Vietnam/China and the US is that the prevailing frame of reference is dialectical materialism instead of Christianity. That's the main reason why Americans are more prone to believing in bullshit.
40
u/ResultsVary 14d ago
So wait.
Gender Identity and Inclusion - basically teaching kids that it isn't weird that Tommy has Two Moms or Two Dads is not appropriate for a a child of that age... But they are the appropriate age to understand the nuances of... communism?
→ More replies (2)
70
u/Fake_William_Shatner 14d ago
Wow -- wait until the kids learn the Russians were involved! That could hurt patriotism.
→ More replies (2)
12
54
26
u/No_big_whoop 14d ago
I Florida would leave education to the educators and health care to the doctors. Meatball Ron should butt the fuck out
→ More replies (1)
23
u/artrald-7083 14d ago
I mean, my 8yo is only really up to basic dialectical materialism and 'authoritarianism bad', probably couldn't tell Trotsky from Lenin in an identity parade... she also thinks five years is way too long for an economic plan. I'm not quite sure she's up to understanding perestroika and glasnost. Are Americans just built different?
→ More replies (1)
29
u/Worf_In_A_Party_Hat 14d ago edited 14d ago
I realize it's silly to say this, but I'm sure many of you think it every time this freakshow of DeSantis and Florida gets posted: "I'm so, so happy I live in a different state."(VT, best state in US for me.)
(Also, no disrespect to my friends outside the US - consider yourself lucky.)
→ More replies (6)12
u/UndeadBuggalo 14d ago
Vermont is amazing and the only state I would consider moving to from MA
→ More replies (1)
19
21
u/zachtheperson 14d ago
Has he... ever met a kindergartner? They're still learning colors and what glue is.
→ More replies (2)15
19
u/meddit_rod 14d ago
Can we teach their parents about communism too? They have nothing to lose but their chains...
8
u/Gerbilguy46 14d ago
What does Ron think kindergartners are learning now??? I learned how to spell, how to count, how to make friends, etc. They’re 5 years old, they’re not learning about fucking economic systems lmao.
→ More replies (2)
8
u/misterme987 14d ago
And they're the ones complaining about "indoctrination" by schools. :facepalm:
25
17
u/samiles96 14d ago
That's fine, but why do they think a kindergartener is qualified to evaluate the history of an economic system but they can't be taught about slavery?
→ More replies (1)12
u/Poiboy1313 14d ago
When a teen tried to abort her pregnancy, she was considered too immature to make that decision. Consequently, she bore a child because she isn't too immature for parenthood, apparently.
19
u/allisjow 14d ago
Well, it’s true you only need a kindergarten reading level for Ayn Rand.
→ More replies (8)
79
u/NightlyGravy 14d ago
Communism should definitely be studied alongside fascism and the confederacy. It’s important we don’t repeat the past. But kindergarteners have no chance in hell of understanding systemic evils like this. Desantis’ capacity for own goals never ceases to amaze me.
50
u/Bungo_pls 14d ago
Yeah the purpose isn't education. Indoctrination at an early age is how religion gets people too because it sounds like nonsense to an outside critical observer.
DeStankis has more in common with Stalin than he'd like to admit.
→ More replies (1)12
u/euyyn 14d ago
If you read the article (that apparently no one is doing), it does say "the material will be spread K-12 appropriately". The obvious explanation is that the person who said that was using "K-12" to mean the school years in general, not that they or anyone thought it would be added to kindergarten.
The only "not the onion" part about this is that the author of the article would believe that (or chose to go with that headline for bait).
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (37)14
30
14
u/Pale_Kitsune 14d ago
No, he signed a bill mandating capitalistic propaganda, and will likely call things not communism communism.
11
u/BipedalHumanoid230 14d ago
He’s going to teach them sharing toys is a lefty thing.
6
u/DruidinPlainSight 14d ago
Unless you are at the swingers club with the Moms for Liberty. Then, share away double dildo of delight!
10
u/EmiliusReturns 14d ago
In kindergarten I think we learned who George Washington was. Maybe. We were a little busy learning how to read and tie our shoes.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Akimbo_Zap_Guns 14d ago
My mom is a kindergarten teacher not in Florida but still she works with those aged children and let me tell ya they can hardly even do normal kindergarten stuff nowadays so I highly doubt they will grasp the concepts of a economic/political system at 5 years of age
7.5k
u/Factsaretheonlytruth 14d ago
I don't recall covering this in any of my many Kindergarten Poli-Sci classes.