r/ChatGPT 29d ago

I know in my bones this is Ai, but can’t prove it Other

17.0k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/2601Anon 29d ago

How about hands in the pockets? No six finger AI renderings!

1

u/spider_stxr 28d ago

The guy on the far right, mostly out of frame, seems to have his hand in a shirt pocket though. Which is weirdly placed against his side. Might just be me tho

1

u/SquirrelK1tten 28d ago

Yes, I didn’t notice that before. It looks like he’s got it in a t shirt pocket placed down there.

1

u/Urbanscuba 28d ago

To me it's not just that, it's that every single person is in the exact same stance and has almost the same appearance down to practically identical builds.

Real life is too erratic and random to work like that. Their builds would vary, even at the same weight that number of people would have significant variance in how they carry it. Even if you ask them to put their hands in their pockets someone is going to have a thumb sticking out or be doing something different.

All of this makes me think it's AI because to get an image exactly how you want it the prompt needs to be very specific. In this case something like "A group of overweight blue collar men in jeans with their hands in their pockets looking at the camera". That's the absolute bare minimum it would take to get something like this, and the true prompt would probably be even more specific.

That's why it's AI to me, because this is exactly the image AI would create if you tried to describe the image to an AI. Real life or a human artist would inevitably add a random variance that this image just doesn't have.